Scribbling Women- Marthe Jocelyn

Scribbling Women book cover

I know I shouldn’t think this way, and I know I’ll be punished for it, but I just love it when bad things happen to people I can’t stand.

Though we might not care to admit it, I’m sure that many of us have felt like this at some point or another in our lives. There’s nothing especially remarkable about the sentiment. What is remarkable is that this quotation is taken from the diary of Sei Shonagon, a tenth century lady-in-waiting at the Imperial Court in Japan. Scribbling Women is a book of remarkable women. Remarkable because of the times they lived in, remarkable because of the stories they wrote down, remarkable because their experiences resonate with the women of today.

Marthe Jocelyn became interested in the legacy left by female diarists when researching her book A Home For Foundlings which introduced her to the importance of the letters of Lady Mary Wortley Montagu, who helped to cure smallpox in Britain by writing letters home from Turkey explaining how the disease was treated there. What knowledge then might be found in the diaries and letters of less prominent women in history? And how would they relate to the experience of modern women?

Taking its title from Nathaniel Hawthorne’s frustrated outburst to his publisher, “America is now given over to a damned mob of scribbling women,” Scribbling Women is a whistle-stop tour of women’s writing in history aimed at, though not exclusively for, young adults. Some of the women may be known to readers, other names will be unfamiliar but all have extraordinary stories to tell. From the letters of Margaret Catchpole, a deported female convict who became one of the early settlers in Australia, to Hatty Jacobs whose story of life as a slave challenged the conscience of America almost every woman has something profound to tell us about her historical period and attitudes to women at the time when she wrote.

I say almost every woman, because I disagree with the inclusion of Daisy Ashford, who wrote The Young Visiters, a novel, as a nine year old. I don’t think that this fitted with the rest of the book which focuses on the experiences of women who lived incredible lives and recorded their memories in non-fiction formats. It’s almost as though Daisy’s story was included as a novelty piece, or curios, and I think that this is reflected in the length of text that the author dedicated to this.

Despite this, I loved this book and my main criticism would be that I think Jocelyn could have taken the concept further to include the stories of even more remarkable women. There are many remarkable women whose stories could have filled the pages, and I would like to see an extended edition, as I think that there would be a market for this book with a greater depth of exploration without it wandering into the scope of an academic text.  I especially liked the way that the story of each woman was linked to the next, comparing their situations or biographies to allow the distance, both physical and chronological, to flow away between the pages.

Zlata Filipovic

A diarist that I really think should have been included: Zlata Filipovic

I noticed that all but one of Marthe Joyce’s women have died, and I think that it would have been good to include some living writers. Zlata Filipovic was a teenage diarist during the war in Sarajevo, and has been compared by many to Anne Frank. However, unlike Anne, her story has had a happy ending. Not only is her diary an important historical record, but Zlata went on to study at Oxford University, and now lives in Dublin. She still writes in support of freedom, and has collaborated on works for children affected by conflict and has been involved writing forewords to projects such as The Freedom Writers Diary, which helps teenagers help themselves and the world around them through writing.

A big thank you to Tundra Books and Marthe Jocelyn for offering me the opportunity to read and review this book. Please check out the Tundra Books website for the chance to win some great Scribbling Women prizes.


12 thoughts on “Scribbling Women- Marthe Jocelyn

  1. Pingback: “Scribbling Women” Blog Tour: Day 4 « Talking with Tundra

  2. Pingback: “Scribbling Women” Blog Tour « Talking with Tundra

  3. Jennifer O

    I’ve never heard of Filipovic. I’d be interested to read her diaries.

    I’m hoping Marthe writes a follow up to this book. I’d be anxious to read that as well.

  4. theveryhungrybookworm

    I think my favorite female author is an Irish author- Eavan Boland. Is she in there? If you haven’t read her poetry, check out “Outside History.”

  5. Teresa

    Fantastic post. I hadn’t heard of Filipovic either, but will have to look for her diaries. The big thing that Scribbling Women did for me as spark a curiousity. Thank you Marthe!

  6. Marthe Jocelyn

    thanks for the names of new Scribblers!

    and thank you for clearly stating your challenge of Daisy’s inclusion. i certainly recognize that she’s an outsider in this company of women, but for me she represented the true state of exuberant scribbling based on observation and imagination, not constrained by expectations or self-censorship – a state we might all benefit from inhabiting on occasion.

    1. Siobhan

      Kudos to that reasoning Marthe, it’s the best that we can all reasonably hope for. Thanks for stopping by to comment. I appreciate it, and I have ordered The Pillow Book after reading Scribbling Women, so you can see that I really was inspired to find out more.

  7. Martha S

    i agree that one of the best things about scribbling women is the eye opening effect of it, making me at any rate determined to look high and low for the scribblers that i know are out there.

  8. Heather

    I love that some of the women who were included we’re perfect role models. They were women trying to survive in difficult times. I doubt that they all would have chosen their difficulties: being ill-supplied and stranded in the Arctic, being transported to Australia. These things did happen and these women dealt with them best they could. What is remarkable is that they left a record.

    Enjoyed your post, particularly that you have suggested a ‘new to me’ scribbler.

  9. stacybuckeye

    Love the quote and think it’s great it came from so long ago! Human nature doesn’t really change, does it?
    This looks fun and I’m adding it to my wish list.

  10. Christinabean

    I am enjoying all of these posts! Zlata Filipovic is someone I’d love to learn more about. Great suggestion!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s